LINN Genki CD Players
LINN Genki CD Players
USER REVIEWS
[Aug 26, 1999]
Charlie Whitaker
an Audio Enthusiast
To me, this product seems nothing less than the Platonic ideal for CD players. My CDs, when played on it, become the Platonically ideal versions of themselves. Amazingly, some recordings which I believed to be sub-standard turn out to be the best of all (especially my EMI pressing of Mahler 2/Rattle/CBSO) and I now realise that it was my previous equipment that was grossly sub-standard. In purchasing, I compared this player with the Roksan Caspian and a player from Micromega (Premium 20?). The Micromega was a decent player with no obvious faults, but not enthralling either. The Caspian is highly regarded at its price, but it soon became apparent that it had been 'engineered' to provide a sound with 'audiophile appeal' - warm and thick in the middle with tizzy detail and solid bass etc. which to me seemed totally ersatz. The Genki, on the other hand, delivers a totally natural, transparent and uncontrived sound. I continue to be amazed by it. Everything I feed it sounds better than I had imagined it would - even with my now greatly raised expectations. Everything comes out sounding more musical - what were previously weighty thumps & wallops in full orchestral passages of high intensity now have clearly defined shape and pitch, and the constituent instruments are clearly identifiable (timpani and contrabassoon, for example). Single melody lines resolve into subtle harmonies. Six piece bands become seven piece bands. Explosions of sound don't hit you, but instead burst over and around you with drenching clarity. And after you finish being amazed by all this, you don't immediately reach for the next CD, because you just want to keep on listening - even to the 'boring' or 'bad' stuff. |
[Apr 21, 2000]
chris benten
Audio Enthusiast
Strength:
Resolution: at least as good as the Arcam 9 and more than the Naim 3.5.
Weakness:
Hot Treble??? System: Similar Products Used: Yamaha CDC-675 - This is not a fair comparison. The Yammy has a 5-disc turntable and is not near as resolute. In fact not even close. That said, it is still a good player. |
[Oct 31, 2000]
mark
Audiophile
Strength:
Soundstage, build quality, features
Weakness:
The cd tray appears to be very flimsy on first observation. After using it for a while, I realize that it is better than I first thought. Yes, the Ikemi has a better sound, but it is over twice the price of the Genki! When I got the Genki home and first listened to it, I was concerned about the sound. It wasn't what I remembered hearing when auditioning CD players. However, after 48 hours of CONSTANT playing, the sound came forth! If you get this unit, let it break in for a couple of days before judging it and don't panic like I did! It improved even more after the first week. The sound can be described as very open with a deep soundstage. I would also say that it is very neutral - not overly bright and no boomy bass. The sound has a presentation of dynamics that I am very impresed with. Its smoothe sound is almost hauntingly good on classical recordings. My wife has said, "I didn't know I was missing so much of the music until I heard this machine". It's as if I don't have to concentrate so much on the "sweet spot" to hear all the music. It seems to project the sound out into the room more than some other players. Similar Products Used: Rega Planet, Rega Planet 2000, NAD 523, NAD Silver series, Arcam Alpha 9, LINN Ikemi |
[Aug 06, 2000]
Stephen Daedalus
Audio Enthusiast
Strength:
Surprisingly subtle: The Genki sneaks up on you, subtly seduces you and compels you to revel in the experience of listening. It's free of the brittleness and of the harshness sometimes associated with digital audio: While not quite "warm," its sound is inescapably natural. The Genki is also a very neutral player, especially in the upper frequencies, and its soundstage is both deep *and* wide. Finally, and despite its rather inauspicious appearance, the Genki is a rugged little player, and is more than capable of taking a knock or two.
Weakness:
Transport and, specifically, tray. The Genki's CD tray is probably the cheapest such device I've seen on any mid- to high-end CD player, and looks fragile to the point of delicacy. The Genki's transport itself is very noisy, is far from graceful (almost shuddering to a stop when ejected), and simply doesn't seem up to par for an upper-tier player. That said, the Genki is pretty much shock proof: A rap to its top or to its side is not sufficient to cause the player to mistrack or otherwise stop playing. OTHER WEAKNESSES: The Genki's variable output seems to be altogether superflous, as its output stages simply don't seem potent enough to adequately drive most power amplifiers. I wasn't too thrilled with the Linn when I first purchased it. I was put off by its shoddy transport, by its light weight and by its inauspicious aesthetic. I also made the mistake of trying to drive my Aragon 8008BB (and highly inefficient Infinity Renaissance 90s) directly by virtue of one of its *two* variable outputs. Similar Products Used: Arcam Alpha 9, Adcom GCD-750, Sony SCD-777ES, YBA CD-3, Resolution Audio CD-55 |
[Dec 03, 2000]
Ro Conte
Audio Enthusiast
Strength:
Natural,unforced delivery
Weakness:
Flimsy drawer,supplied interconnects I must admit I was somewhat disappointed with the sound of this CD player when I first fired it up at home. However, I didn't panic and allowed it to run in over a couple of days. It's sound definately became more open and dynamic but still not to the extent I had expected. Then, I decided to experiment with interconnects. I substituted the supplied Linn interconnect with an old Ixos 103 lead. This brought about improvements in detail, bass depth and imagery but it still sounded overbright.I then tried an Ecosse Reference CA1 purchased for £50. WOW!!! This really got things rockin'. The soundstage grew bigger,instruments sounded lifelike and the bass was just awesome. It's unbelievable just how much improvement can be made just by changing leads. For all of you out there who have bought a Genki and are still using the supplied leads, do yourself a favour, you'll be surprised! Similar Products Used: Arcam Alpha 5+ |