Meridian 508.24 CD Players
Meridian 508.24 CD Players
[Jan 15, 1999]
John
an Audiophile
If there is a player that is so well thourght out then this is it. Excellent transport where you get the benefit of a drawer and top loading mechanism in the same unit. |
[Jan 25, 1999]
bryan
an Audio Enthusiast
Had just finished listening to a few choice albums on a friend's Linn LP-12 then went off to audition CD players. Naturally, it was a bit disappointing, in comparison. In NYC however, you can hear a lot of brands in one day! Arcam 9 sounded smooth but sort of slow paced and muddy. The Naim 3.5 sounded very strange with its super fast pace, and was overall not as smooth as the Arcam, especially in the Treble where it actually was hard edged. The power supply upgrade ($750) helped, but not really that much. I realized this was going to be difficult. Next, the Krell 300 player- ouch, my ears! The Krell had such a bright treble that it made listening into the upper mids and highs pure work. I thought that the Krell lacked palpability (my first criteria for evaluating components) in a big way. The Audio Note tubed CD player at S.B.S.- mmmm... really smooth, more analogue, but still a bit harsh on top and lacking full midrange detailI- I couldn't believe that at $4000 I would have to settle this much. No player was revealing midrange information like the Linn LP-12. I began to envision the long process of selling all of my CDs and looking for a table. I heard ghostly laughs of Michael Fremer all the way to the next audio store. The Audio Research CD2- lots more detail all over the frequency range, but still not enough palpability. Everything seemed flat and mechanical compared to the LP. Still, things were definitely improving. Next was the Sonic Frontiers SFCD-1. For some reason I was not expecting much, but this player had very inviting qualities, especially a non-fatiguing ease of presentation. Definite palpability. 100% opposite of the Krell. But it wasn't long before my critical side came out. Detail was missing, especially compared to the ARC. Oh so now I get it- either you can have detail OR you can have palpability, but not both. Maybe I would just by the CAL CL-15. This was a nice player, similar to the ARC, with a little less refinement but I was not getting into the music any more. Either it was the monoblock Krells they were being played through (the easiest way to suck the life out of music) or it was past time for a break.The next day- improvements! The Wadia 850 was a nice blend of good things. The sound was finally musical while inner details were preserved. I started to think I could keep my CDs. The 830 for less $$$ also sounded nice. However (I like to criticize things) the tonal balance seemed a little weird- like certain frequencies had different priorities over others, like someone was 'engineering' the sound. Next, the BAT VK-D5. This is the strangest player of them all. Super detailed mids and palpability, but also funny frequency response like the Wadia. With the BAT, it is clear that the company has their opinion about how they think music SHOULD sound- but so what? They have good taste!- emphasizing midrange detail and palpability. This would be the most fun CD player to own so far, though the Wadia may be a better conservative choice. I thought I would go back to hear the Wadia again at Stereo Exchange. |
[Jul 10, 1999]
Andrew
an Audiophile
I heard this cd player today matched to a pair of NHT 2.5i's and the Krell KAV-300i integrated, and I can definately say it's up there with the best cd players I've heard. I couldn't believe how quiet everything was (background) and the resolution and clarity was unbelievable. I only had the chance to demo the player with some old remastered jazz recordings and even on these the player still sounded oh so smooth and natural. I have a friend who owns the 508.20 and I must admit that to me, the 508.20 doesn't get down and boogie as much as I would like it to. On really dynamic rock music it almost seems to take everything too politely, and it also doesn't seem to have the rhythm of some other players I've heard (Naim 3.5 for instance) As such, I wanted to hear the 24-bit version with some serious rock music instead of the standard 'demo' music you usually listen to when auditioning systems (light jazz, etc) Unfortunately I wasn't able to at the time, but nonetheless what I heard on jazz was definately a 5-star performance. A marked improvement over the 508.20 to my ears, especially in the areas of rhythm and overall musicality (I couldn't stop tapping my toes listening to the 508.24!! That's not something I do with the 508.20) |
[Aug 05, 1999]
N Diemer
an Audiophile
System:Classe CAP-151 |
[Nov 24, 1999]
Kenyon Keys
Audiophile
Strength:
It has a true analog sound,I dont have to listen to alot of digital jitter like other players.When I listen to the 508.24 I dont get listening fatigue any more I can turn up the volume on my preamp and hear smooth highes a clean midrange and a tight base.It lets your hear all the music that is encoded on your CD"s,and it is upgradeable and ready for future formats.I talked to A rep from meridian corparation on the phone,and he told me that the player will be supporting the super audio cd format in the future.It is built like like a tank, and the anti jitter device that it incorpoarates is one of the best.
Weakness:
They are exspensive,but if your in to high end audio you can not do any better,I bought mine of the audio review website for 1800.00 thats about half the retail price. My search is over.I will be able to live with this unit for a long time,Dont take my word for it,try one out at your Meridian Dealer. Similar Products Used: Sony,Rotel 900 series,toshiba, |
[Jul 07, 2001]
Manuel Ochoa
Audiophile
Strength:
analog-like sound. totally non-fatiguing
Weakness:
none I used to have a respectable CAL CDP, then heard a friend's 508.24 and realized my player was "the weakest link!" Naturally, I obsessed for 3 months (ok, make that 5 months), reading everything ever written about digital front ends, including the new formats coming to market. I then audioned every high end system under $5k, and even a few just over it, thuough I did not get into separates. Anyway, all these players sounded great, no doubt about it, they were better than my CAL player...... I nearly bought the Levinosn 39 (I know it costs more than the rest), but then borowed my friends 508.24 again, just for *^its and giggles...... and low and behold, I had to have it. apparently, Meridian now offers a flagship DVD/CD player, so few retailers have these units around, so I figured, screw 'em, I'll buy a used one. $2400 later and I am the happiest man in audio nirvana. Similar Products Used: AR, BAT, Wadia, Linn, Levinson, BAT |
[Feb 24, 1999]
Rob
an Audiophile
I have been planning a full system purchase for about six months now, listening to just about everything within reach. I now believe that one of the most critical steps to getting a great sounding system, is finding a dealer that really knows how to make great sound. I can't tell you how many dealers can't even get good sound out of great gear. There are so many posibilities with all the different components, cables, room placement, tweaks, etc., that making the right purchase (the first time!) requires either a lot of luck, or a very skilled and patient dealer. The latter of which is probably even harder to find than the former. |
[Feb 25, 1999]
foster
an Audiophile
i've been buying and listening to stereo components for 35 years, and the Meridian 508.24 may well be the most musical component i've owned. I auditioned Krell, Micromega, BAT, and Sonic Frontiers players, none of which compare with the Meridian. |
[Feb 19, 1999]
Ken
an Audiophile
I have owned the Meridian 508.24 for about 7 months now and could not be happier. |
[Oct 11, 1999]
Walter
Audiophile
This is a great sounding cd player, and that is coming from someone who used to find cds unlistenable. I compared the Meridian 508.24 to the Audio Research CD-1, not a fair match since the Meridian is a generation newer. The AR sounds quite good, and is available for a little over $1,000 in the used market. I recommend it for people who want to spend in that price range. But the Meridian is the hands down winner. It is better across the board. It simply extracts more music from the cds. Perhaps most noteworthy is that there was nothing noteworthy. It did not over- or under-emphasize any part, just gave what was there. |