Philips DVDQ50AT Progressive Scan DVD Player DVD Players
Philips DVDQ50AT Progressive Scan DVD Player DVD Players
[Nov 27, 2001]
Ashar Khan
Casual Listener
Strength:
sharp & crisp picture,sexy & sleek look,advanced circuitry & all possible connections,price, etc,etc,etc.
Weakness:
Made in China!!!! I use DVD players for movies and am a videophile.Thus I cannot compromise on picture quality.Quality of material used,weight of machine,chassis feel and the overall performance of what the DVD player outputs on a TV signal,are equally important to me......Till I saw this machine and lost faith in my belief system.My machine is made in China and says it's designed in Holland.My scepticsm around this issue vanished when I saw the picture the Q 50 produces.Amazing!!The colors are vivid,lines straight,no chroma bug,no bleeding and an extreeeemmmmly sharp picture.Just try it on an interlace mode before trying progressive scan and you'll get a feel of what this machine is offering at a baseline.I don't care about the ergonomics of the remote control and issues like the display panel (which is actually quite creative and scintilating).This is because we all have central Intelli remotes for our equipments ( hopefully),esp.if we are using progressive scan machines.Just look at what you are getting for the price; a DCDI chip,digital outs,digital circuitry and all the essential component connections.I think adding a decoder is a waste,yet this machine still retains it's sleek looks despite the 2 in 1 function.Please refer to www.hometheatrehifi.com for a detailed review on benchmark tests of this machine.This is the most authoritative and intelligent site on Progressive Scan DVD players with lab results; period!.They list all available players and have a comprehensive comparison available.Anyone who wants to be critical about this machine's functioning,please refer to this site.Just because something is available a little cheaper,we should refrain from criticising it.This is a mind set problem and is apparent in a couple of reviews below.We ,as consumers,should be happy that we are the winners as Digital equipment is available for less price.Let's enjoy what we have and be objective about what the end result is.In Q50's case,it is one awesome picture. Similar Products Used: Marantz DV18 THX Ultra DVD Player,other high end players |
[Nov 26, 2001]
Brian
Audiophile
Strength:
It makes rich Hong Kong high-ender very mad.
Weakness:
Not made in Hong Kong. Is that a sin to be made in Singapore? Mr. Sunny compared it with $5K top line Pioneer and trash this $0.5K DVD player like a red eye bull. Comma... I would put it a 5+ star for value rating just because somebody do that. For $4.5K difference, I would buy a flat HDTV and the improvement over old TV would be much more significant. If you are a audio fan, half of that can give you high end SACD (I won't mention the name, so he could not jump on it). Let's give a review for a 500 bucks player straight. |
[Nov 17, 2001]
Jaidev Patel
Audio Enthusiast
Strength:
Excellent Audio, Progressive Scan, and Interlaced mode. Supposedly plays DVD-R, DVD+RW too (NZ model specs)
Weakness:
No backlight on remote buttons, small buttons. I don't know where the guy above got his player from, since mine has no problems at all. Ringing Philips NZ, they say the initial player shipments to US had a few problems, i.e. Chroma Bug, and NTSC picture alignment.. Similar Products Used: Sony 700p, Pioneer DV434 |
[Dec 13, 2001]
John
Audio Enthusiast
Strength:
video quality. Dcdi chip
Weakness:
none This is an awesome player. Video quality blows away machines that cost much more. The guy that give it a low rating is too critical of a machine that only costs $500. Similar Products Used: sony |
[Jan 02, 2002]
Paul
Casual Listener
IS it me or is everybody posting here severly lacking |
[Jan 06, 2002]
hase
Casual Listener
Strength:
very good picture quality in s-video
Weakness:
progressive scan output did not work with my TV unfortunately, the progressive scan feature did not work on my Sony KV-27FS12. I will probably exchange it for a Pany 91. for those who are interested in the Q50, make sure the store has a good return policy -- you might not get a perfect one the first time around. |
[Jan 20, 2002]
Me!
Audiophile
Strength:
Awesome Picture & Sound, Sleek look
Weakness:
on screen menu - will take a little getting use to Overall I like the performance from this dvd player so far... This is not the first dvd player I have had, I feel it's up there with other high-end dvd players. Similar Products Used: Sony DVPNS700P |
[Nov 29, 2001]
Al Noor
Audio Enthusiast
Strength:
Picture and sound
Weakness:
No text on song played in CD and MP3 and weak fast forward. The picture in non progressive scan is much better than other similar price products, and the sound (for CD) is as good as any other using digital output. Similar Products Used: Marantz 4200 and Pioneer 444 |
[Dec 13, 2001]
James
Audio Enthusiast
Strength:
1. Sage FLI2200 progressive output
Weakness:
1. Very slow operation I buyed this product due to built-in Dolby digital & DTS Similar Products Used: Panasonic, Pionner, Sony |
[Dec 10, 2001]
Steven
Audiophile
Strength:
Extremely good video quality
Weakness:
Getting used to its looks The Q50 is a fantastic product for a videophile. Similar Products Used: Sony DVP9000S |