Panasonic PV-VS4821 VCRs
Panasonic PV-VS4821 VCRs
USER REVIEWS
[Jun 09, 2003]
rj55jones
Audio Enthusiast
Strength:
features
Weakness:
video clarity (or lack of it) My results have been pretty poor. I wish I had bought it locally so I could return it. I'll try and get it serviced, because I can't believe Panasonic would release a product with performance this bad. Similar Products Used: my older non-SVHS Panasonic has always worked great |
[Feb 19, 2002]
Todd Dissinger
AudioPhile
Strength:
As usual with Panasonic, good SP picture. Lots of hookups.
Weakness:
VERY noisy. Amazingly noisy for a Panasonic. And the buttons feel very cheap and unresponsive. I have seen $99 Walmart specials that were better. Clunky, cheap and not worth the money. A big step backwards for Panasonic VCRs. Similar Products Used: JVC HR-S4500 |
[Feb 10, 2002]
Andy Wehrle
AudioPhile
Strength:
Awesome picture quality at SP speed in SVHS mode, indistinguishable from DVD, better than standard VHS models in recording in standard VHS mode at all speeds. Lightning-fast rewind and FF. Commercial Advance is cool. So far it has held up well, although it''s still new. . S-video and RF cables are included with the VCR. The manual timer programming is easy, I doubt I''ll ever use VCR+Gold.
Weakness:
Picture quality is not as good in SVHS mode at SLP speed, picture in all speeds in SVHS-ET mode stinks, it is so full of video noise it looks like a very distant TV channel. Inital setup of the VCR is somewhat difficult, it has auto clock set but in my case it didn''t work right. It was also hard to get the VCR to tune in VHF/UHF air channels when first plugged in, even with an antenna. This VCR is not a good editor, there is no FEH or jog/shuttle, and the counter will only show on the TV screen for a few seconds if you press DISPLAY on the remote, it does not show on the unit''s LCD display. Also, it has front A/V jacks but only for composite video, so every time I want to hook up my Hi8 camcorder using its S-video terminal I have to drag the VCR out of the TV cabinet and disconnect the DSS reciever. Commercial advance is a neat feature, but it only works off DSS and not off VHF/UHF air channels. Also, it doesen''t always fast forward through all the ads. I''m not sure how the VCR detects commercials, but sometimes it gets it wrong and stops FF-ing in the middle of the commercials, or continues into the program. Index search doesen''t seem to work right, it always overshoots or st I was looking to get a Super VHS VCR for the purpose of being able to record off DSS and my Hi8 camcorder with less loss in picture quality than regular VHS. There were only three models of SVHS in any of the local electronics oulets, a Mitsubishi something, a JVC HR-S3900U, and the Panasonic PV-VS4821, which I chose because it was the most expensive, and, in general, more expensive equals better quality. I have had mixed results from this VCR. It works well overall but some charachteristics are disappointing to me. I think it was a mistake to purchase for me because it''s not a good editor, but I would recommend it if you have a TV with S-video input and a high-quality source such as DSS, Hi8, or DV, and want to dub and record shows but not edit. Be prepared to shell out extra cash for SVHS cassettes, because ET mode stinks with a capital S. There is a way to get around that, though. The VCR uses a mechanical sensor similar to the write-protect sensor to tell if you''ve put in an SVHS tape. If you look carefully at the bottom of an SVHS cassette, you can see a small hole in the groove that runs along the edge of the cassette that a VHS cassette doesn''t have. Drill that hole in a VHS cassette, and the VCR thinks you''ve put in an SVHS cassette and will do a regular SVHS recording instead of an ET one. The result is almost indistinguisable from what you''d get with a real SVHS cassette. Similar Products Used: Panasonic Standard VHS PV-9451, very similar, see my review of that one. Sony SLV-751HF VHS more than 10 years old, SL-HF-600 Betamax more than 15 years old. |
[Jul 18, 2001]
Scott Pickering
Audio Enthusiast
Strength:
Nice silver finish
Weakness:
Poor cheap construction I'm adding onto my last review. I have returned my Panasonic vcr as I was not impressed with it and its quality and construction. I exchanged it for a JVC HR-S5910 which is almost the same price, but $30 cheaper. With that unit you also get frlying erase heads and insert editting which the Panasonic doesn't have. I did however give up the picture noise filtering going JVC. The JVC 5910 compared to the Panasonic 4821 was like this: Similar Products Used: Others from previous review plus JVC HR-S5910 |
[Jul 06, 2001]
Mike
Audio Enthusiast
Strength:
Tape Transport, SVHS ET
Weakness:
Color (Silver uggg!), NO front S-video input Bought this machine but returned it a couple weeks later as it could not compare with the older models 4820 and 9670 (see reviews). Added to this it is only available in silver which did not match with my existing system. Similar Products Used: Panasonic 9670, 4820, JVC 4800, |
[Sep 10, 2001]
Steve
Audiophile
Strength:
None
Weakness:
Featherweight construction, crappy transport, poor picture quality, poor recording quality, cheesy display, this is Super VHS? Bought this at Sound Advice, tried it out for a couple days, returned it and got a Mitsubishi HS-U776 instead. I already have a JVC 9600 top of the line S-VHS VCR, and wanted another one to dub tapes. The JVC has a great picture and tuner but the transport is not built to handle heavy duty use, even though it is the top of the line model. The new Mitsubishi that I got to replace the Panasonic is the best value I've found for $230. It has much better construction and it has a much better transport. You can notice this right away. The picture quality is much better than the Panasonic and it is truly a Super VHS deck. The Mits has a better display and remote as well. The tuner is far superior to the Panasonic's too. The Panasonic is a piece of crap and I was happy to get the Mitsubishi instead. Similar Products Used: JVC 9600 S-VHS, Mitsubishi HS-U776 S-VHS |
[Sep 16, 2001]
Adam Langdon
Audiophile
Strength:
I'm not seeing any.
Weakness:
Read previous reviews - everything. I should have listened to them. I didn't think this machine could be THAT bad, but it is. I should have paid more attention to the previous postings here which called this machine a cheap piece of crap. It certainly is. I didn't think Panasonic could make such a bad machine because I've owned previous VHS and SVHS models and they have been superb. What is going on with Panasonic? This machine should have the "Acme" or "Brtand X" name on it and not Panasonic. It feels like it is built of cardboard. I have used it for 2 weeks now and that's too late to send it back, so I'm going to junk it and find another brand to buy - and never buy Panasonic again. Similar Products Used: JVC 9600 & previous Panasonic models |
[Dec 17, 2001]
Herbert Cornfed
Audio Enthusiast
Well I replaced my Panasonic PV-V4660 (great vcr) with this new PV-VS4821. There's good, bad and ugly parts about the VCR. |
[Dec 03, 2001]
Romu
Audio Enthusiast
Strength:
High picture quality, both in playback and s-vhs recording
Weakness:
SLP recording To all readers: Please don't let be fooled by all these negative reviews. This is a great product. Let me explain why. Similar Products Used: Sharp VCR, old Panasonic |
[Jan 24, 2002]
Matt
Audiophile
I got the first one in September. After 1 week of normal use, the unit started to make a large hissing sound when playing or recording a tape. I returned it and got another one. Had it for 3 weeks. It never made any noise, but was not happy with the picture quality. I have digital cable with S-Video out and S-Video input on my TV. I tried recording on SVHS tape as well as good quality VHS tape. The SVHS recordings were better, but image was not quite as good as the origional and looked pixelated. My 5 year old normal Sony VHS VCR recorded better. I took the Panasonic back and got a Mitsubishi HS-U795. It was marked down to $250, but origional cost $550 when it came out in '99-2000. The Mits VCR makes the Panasonic look like "My First Sony". Image quality is amazing. Playing back store-bought tapes and TV shows recorded on SVHS tape looks close to DVD quality. |