Fanfare FM FM-2G Tuners
Fanfare FM FM-2G Tuners
USER REVIEWS
[Mar 10, 2007]
Steven
AudioPhile
Strength:
Very easy to install, no need for maintenance, decent reception.
Weakness:
None
Customer Service
Similar Products Used: None |
[Feb 16, 2004]
AudioPhile
Strength:
For the FM-2G..none. If you want the BEST omnidirectional results, buy a #15-2164 antenna from Radio Shack for $14.99. You may have to search, since it was in the 2003 catalog, but not the 2004. Put it in the attic, or better yet, up on a roof. A cheap way to go without getting involved with the more expensive Yagi setup and the needed rotor.(since a Yagi is directional) I have to say that the guys at Audio Dimensions at Woodward & 13.5 Mile took back the Fanfare without a problem and gave me a refund.
Weakness:
When a simple dipole antenna, stretched properly, can outperform a $95. 'state of the art'antenna, something is wrong!! I am sorry that the FM-2G doesn't work like some magazine reviewers would like you to believe. If you're into music, you know there are a lot of ways to waste money out there. Be careful.(especially on wire! Read the speaker wire story on www.roger-russell.com AMAZING!!!) After reading all the info on the Fanfare website, and reviewing the literature they sent me a few years ago, I decided to get one and "hear" for myself how good this thing really is. I compared it to a Radio Shack "Omnidirectional" antenna, #15-2164, mounted in the attic of a 2 story house. Same exact location. Same coax. I took meter reading on my Modafarri modified McIntosh MR71 tuner for various stations, up & down the dial....some strong, some not, some local and some distant. ("distant" for me is about 70 miles to Lansing from my north of Detroit area) I then substituted the Fanfare and took the readings again. Across the dial, they were lower. I was amazed!! A $95. antenna getting whipped by a $14.99 crossed dipole!! I ran the test again. Same results.... Some of the strongest stations went from a 7.5 to a 7. Weaker ones went down from a 5.5 to a 4.4. Still further, weaker stations simply fell off my dial.(like Lansing) In NO CASE, did the FM-2G do better than The Shack antenna. I also compared a simple dipole hooked up to a McIntosh MAC1500 receiver. Same results, unfortunately, for the Fanfare. Similar Products Used: Simple dipole, mounted, and here is the key: CORRECTLY. Radio Shack #15-2164 antenna, omnidirectional for attic or roof mount. |
[Dec 16, 2002]
halfnelson
Audio Enthusiast
Strength:
1) Strength, what strength? Are you talking about the absent strength LED indication while using the ST-2 ? 2) My wife is happy
Weakness:
Only mine is to blame, because I believed that a smart guy could defy the physics laws ! Only outdoor directional antenna can provide strong and clean signal, period. This review is for fanfare FM-2G, Magnum Dynalab ST-2 and Metz OEM model: Living in a flat in the nearby of Paris, I was looking for a better indoor performer than the given dipole antenna which is usually supplied in every tuner’s package. A friend of mind warmly recommended the equivalent (original making?) Metz AM/FM model which IMHO is actually the same reference as the Magnum Dynalab ST-2 and Fanfare FM2-G versions (have a look at Metz website), but at a cheaper price. I found myself rather sceptical while opening the packaging; it looks like a CB or Marine antenna that has been tailored (tweaked?) for FM reception, and the ugly/ utilitarian style combined with the rather bulky design (whip length) don’t integrate very well with a nice looking living room. OK, OK, you can hide it behind a curtain or furniture but at the expense of reception quality: in ST-2/ FM-2G manual it is clearly recommended to keep the antenna away from walls (a big challenge for an indoor antenna !), TV mast and any reflective vertical surface (so what is the mounting bracket for?) to avoid the ST-2/ FM-2G becoming directional. So here we start the painstaking process to find out the right antenna location which would combine the best FM reception with the famous Woman Acceptance Factor. But let’s start with the reception quality first; as my tuner provides two FM antenna inputs, I could plug the ST-2/ FM-2G in direct comparison with the cheapo dipole antenna which hangs along the wall. After scanning across the FM band and searching the best ST-2/ FM-2G locations & positions everywhere in the room (my wife was outside for shopping ) during a whole afternoon, I came up to the bitter conclusion; my dipole is better and not only by a small margin! Not only the strength meter indicated 3 more LED’s with the dipole than with the ST-2, but it also provided a far cleaner sound with less hiss and noise. Even worse, with the ST-2/ FM-2G some radio stations (usually strong and good )could’nt tune in stereo, or simply kept muted ! I couldn’t believe my dirty $2 dipole could beat the 60 $ “state of the art” passive FM antenna, so I double-checked again and again all connectors, coaxial cable, locations etc…. with no success . The ST-2/ FM-2G simply doesn’t make it. Similar Products Used: cheapo dipole and various indoor active antennas |
[Jan 19, 2000]
Arthur Kwan
Audiophile
Strength:
Relatively cheaper than the comparable products. Good reception
Weakness:
Not that fancy looking In Hong Kong, we have all the high buildings and have the same reception problems as in other metropolitans. I bought this antenna through the Web and it costs around HK$800, which is good value compared to other brand name. The similar product of Dynalab sells for HKD1,200 and as I hear, the reception ability is poorer than the Fanfare antenna I bought. With the Fanfare, not only do you get clearer music, you get more texture as well as much better higher frequencies, as well. Similar Products Used: Magnum Dynalab of Canada antenna |
[Nov 10, 2000]
gokhan senturk
Audiophile
Strength:
Makes reception maximum, Signal level allways max.
Weakness:
background noise, terrible background sound I like radio very much. When I read this miracle antenna, it got me very excited. Because after I purchased it my radio problem should have been solved. But when I connect the cable to the antenna week stations disappeared. When Similar Products Used: ordinary transvers 2 aluminium rots (no name, 75 ohm, 5$) |
[Jun 15, 2000]
Stephan Laska
Audio Enthusiast
Strength:
construction, good looks
Weakness:
none Upon opening the package, I was inpressed at the excellent workmanship tha went into the final product. The FM-2G was then tested by connecting it to a Fanfare FT1A tuner, a Nachimichi TA1A reciever (quartz synthesized tuner - digital), and a Marantz 2238B reciever (all analog unit circa 1978. The antenna was tested on the 1st floor of a 2 floor wooden house. There were no sources of RF interferance nearby (such as transmiter towers, electric motors, cellular phone, etc.) Similar Products Used: variety of dipoles (radio shack and others), roof mounted mutli-element dipole, long wire asymetrical |
[Jun 01, 2000]
Vadim
Audiophile
Strength:
Simply the best indoor antenna Living in a rural area I have tried over 20 room antennas from various manufacturers (including amplified ones and AudioPrism’s phase array model), and Fanfare’s antenna was the best. The only antenna that works better is a 12-feet Yagi on the roof. Similar Products Used: See review |
[Jan 19, 2000]
Tim
Audiophile
Strength:
Relatively small size, gain What a great, essential product! Similar Products Used: Rooftop dipoles |
[Sep 27, 1999]
John Lum
an Audiophile
Used with: Fanfare FM FT-1; Creek T43; Parasound T/DQ-1600 |
[Dec 23, 2000]
Matt
Audio Enthusiast
Strength:
Convienent Size
Weakness:
Sensitive to location I got this antenna with a Fanfare FT-1A tuner. The construction of the unit is nice, quite sturdy. Its also very compact. When it was indoors I wasn't really impressed witht he quality of my FM. When it went outdoors things weren't much better until I mounted it above the eaves. Its seem that to get this thing working its best you really have to mount it high, in an area free from obstructions so it can receive from all sides. Its not what most of us want to hear, but some laws just are. If you want good clean distortion-free deep bass the loudspeaker has to move a lot of air and this entails a large driver and and an enclosure of a corresponding size. And if you want the system to play loud and clean, you need alot of power (go away SET/horn aficiandos). And if you want the best FM reception possible the antenna has to be mounted high and outside. No way around it. Which leaves me only to recommend this antenna for apartments. If you have a house I would go yagi style. If your going to go through all the trouble of running shielded cable and mounting outside and atop a mast you might was well put one of those spidery things out there instead. And this little unit costs almost as much as a yagi style. Similar Products Used: None |