ESS AMT 1B Floorstanding Speakers
ESS AMT 1B Floorstanding Speakers
[Jan 09, 2001]
Paul
Audiophile
Strength:
Clarity, Detail, Imaging, Power Handling, Sound Field Depth,
Weakness:
Narrow vertical dispersion Heil, room placement is crucial, Heavy To Move The Heil AMT (Air Motion Driver) is perhaps one of the best high frequency drivers ever conceived. Driven with clean power and good source material, AMTs can deliver such nuances in detail and imaging that is truely amazing. The AMT design is actually found in other manufacturers of fine loudspeakers, especially in Europe - just do a search for "AMT Heil" on Google. The AMT 1Bs and their successors (see below) use the bipolar design allowing for a more open sound stage, though bipolar designs require a bit more care with how you place them in a room due to rear surface reflections. The AMT 1Bs and AMT Monitor's were built like a rock, weighing in approx. 90 and 110 pounds respectivly. Similar Products Used: AMT Monitors |
[Jan 08, 2001]
Wendell Cotton
Audio Enthusiast
Strength:
Heil. Midrange bass. Solid on the upper-bottom range. High range is incomparably good.
Weakness:
Replaced the foam after 14 years The AMT1b's have been a solid performer since we bought them in 1978. Polycones still look and perform as new. Had to replace the foam after 14 years but that was easily accomplished. Drove 80 miles to the ESS shop in Sacramento and everything was there. Even bought new grill covers that had been scratched to heck by a cat. NO MORE CATS! :-) Similar Products Used: Noen really - waited to buy the best the first time. |
[Jan 01, 2001]
talal el sayyed
Audiophile
Strength:
everithing
Weakness:
none This for AMT1A Similar Products Used: infinity,vandersteen |
[Mar 03, 1999]
norm
I worked for ESS (Sacramento Calif)in the mid to late seventies. Strangely enough I never did buy any speakers for my own use. At that time was in love with the midrange of the 'Bozak Symphony' - they were my speaker of choice. However I did purchase seperately the 'Heil' driver - at the time sold under the name 'Elite'. When added to the Bozak, which needed a boost in the top-end the sound was quite amazing. I still have those 'Bozaks' although now they are stuffed neatly away in my closet. I am plan on refurbishing them later this year. I am currently running NHT 2.5i. I am looking forward to the comparision between the two. Norm...... |
[Aug 31, 2001]
Al M.
Audio Enthusiast
Strength:
Treble ambience, transparency
Weakness:
woofer mis-match and too low crossover These are legends but the sound is dated in the midrange and bass so I have rebuilt them into a 3 way using another legend driver, Yamaha NS1000 berrylium midrange and 2 7" Scanspeak carbon woofers. Sound much better than the old AMT 1C bookshelf units. Check out the pictures on this photo website: http://communities.ninemsn.com.au/berryliumthing/berryliumheilss.msnw |
[Aug 28, 2001]
Peter Yip
Audiophile
Strength:
The highs are really fantastic. Forget about the ribbon and the ceramics.... Only the electrostatic or Magenplanar can match
Weakness:
Very strong magnetic field: can destroy your TV screen or your analog watch I bought a used pair of Heil tweeters, bass units + passive radiators and crossover ( ie. AMT 1b without the wood cabinet ). I have only used the Heil unit to match my desktop Mission 751. What more can I say? Simply perfect treble, 100 marks. Period. |
[Jan 29, 2000]
Gordon Liss
Audio Enthusiast
Strength:
Unbeliveable sound and quality. Value for the money. Tuff. Unless you are running a piece of &^%#$@ amp, you can't hurt them.
Weakness:
No current sales available in the U.S. I wrote the original review on these speakers and I'm back to follow up. Simply put, these baby's are the most unreal listening experience you'll ever have. I have heard many other brands, and NONE can compare. I used to sell audio and I have heard plenty of the competitors and they can't compete. Remember too that this design is at least 20 years old. They sounded awesome before C.D.'s were around. Now with C.D.'s, it is like a musical orgasm. I honestly can't believe some of the nick picking that I have read on this site regarding these speakers. Get real! For the price, you can't get ANYTHING better. They even sound better than speakers twice thier price. The only, and I mean only thing that is a negative is thier size, and I've seen some potential 5 star ratings knocked down a few notches due to that. Personaly, I would never give up such an astonishing piece of musical equipment because of size. If you want a listening experience that can't be rivaled, make the space. However, if you absolutely can't fit them, look to some of the other smaller ESS's maybe. Get a pair of these baby's if you can. On a rating scale of 1-5 I give them a 20!!! Similar Products Used: None - Why stray from perfection |
[Mar 31, 2000]
Mark Willens
Audio Enthusiast
Strength:
Sound is superb.
Weakness:
Grill covering and frame can work loose. I've owned a pair of these AMT1B's since 1977. They have withstood the test of time and four moves. Everyone is impressed with their sound. The Heil component looks weird but, what the heck, it produces a pristine sound that fills the room. I bought these during the days when you really had to shop, listen and compare before buying (and when I had the time to do so). I've noted that the Heil tweeter-midrange component has a better side-to-side dispersion than up and down. I have slightly elevated the front of the speaker using a shim to counter that perception. If you own a pair of these speakers, ESS will send you replacement woofers and passive bass radiators for a few hundred dollars. Back in 1993 the overhaul cost me about $275 with shipping (they wanted the old woofers back, too). Replacement was extremely easy. Reason for replacement: the foam lining of the woofer cone and passive radiator deteriorated to the point that holes were letting air escape. I was informed by ESS when I called them that the foam deteriorates over time, primarily from bacteria which eats it. Regardless of the etiology of the deterioration, I was promptly sent the replacement woofers and radiators and they fit and worked great. I'll be sad when my four-year old goes at those speakers with some sharp object (which is inevitable, right?). I do so hate being a fatalist. |
[Aug 22, 1999]
Ben Bacon
an Audio Enthusiast
I have owned my AMT1s for more than 25 years-one is on its 2nd woofer, one's on its 3rd. I agree with the two somewhat critical reviews posted, much as I love these speakers. I think the answer is they simply can't play loud. That is to say, they can take just about anything without damaging them, but they won't sound very good. The diaphragm's geometry changes when it moves. The longer the motion, the more this will affect the performance. Because the ends of the diaphragm tend to hold the folds in place, the center portion actually moves quite a bit more than the rest. (I just confirmed this with a battery) This is where the touching must occur when overdriven. Nobody seems yet to have mentioned the most important tweak for these speakers (pyramid cabinets only): Loosen the retaining bolts and insert a pencil under the front of the Heil unit. This will place the diaphragm in roughly the same plane as the woofer. It makes a big difference, if only to tilt the dispersion pattern up toward people's ears. |
[Aug 19, 1999]
John McMurdo
an Audiophile
I have owned a pair of AMT 1bs since 1979 . I replaced the passive radiators and reconed the speakers last year (parts from ESS). Yes, the heil unit is impressive, but, on program material with dense high frequency information or when listening to less than top quality recordings or CDs they can sound downright harsh. Using better than average electronics, cables, etc. helps a lot, but I find that after 20 years I am still tweaking in order to tame excessive brilliance/harshness. I also agree with other reviewers that the bass speakers are not well balanced with the Heil Units. Despite this, I should point out that with every upgrade I make in the rest of my system, these speakers always sound better. The rest of my system consists of a high end Denon CD Player (Model?), Rega Planar 3, Electron Kinetics Eagle 2a Amp, Superphon Revelation Preamp, NAK Cassette, and antiquated speaker cable (Thinking of replacing speaker cable to Kimber 4TC which I hear has good bass and sweet highs). A local, in the know, audio guy has suggested the possibility of modifying these speakers for biwiring - and predicts a big improvement - hmmm. Anyway, I think these were great speakers, but if I could afford to lay out $1200 (CAN) or so I would definitely opt for something else. |