Madisound Sledgeling (Kit) Floorstanding Speakers
Madisound Sledgeling (Kit) Floorstanding Speakers
USER REVIEWS
[Sep 11, 2002]
PMartinez
Audio Enthusiast
Strength:
Very few. The response curves of the speakers tell it all. The European designs of the tweeters yield stunning results.
Weakness:
It'll take a little time, but you won't regret it a bit and you'll have the handyman's satifaction. This is a follow up on the Madison Odin speaker. I was never quite satisified with the high end on these speakers. I felt that they were too 'echoic', i.e., the decay was too long on many high notes. To solve this problem I replaced the Seas tweeters with a Vifa XT25TG30 and the result was quite stunning. Now these speakers are a pure joy to listen to. If you really want to save money, you can build a great sounding monitor speaker from Parts Express with the following parts: Parts from Parts Express: #300 – 704 - .22 cu ft cabinet #300 – 708 - .55 cu ft cabinet ( ½ in MDF) #091- 1245 - Dayton gold-plated binding posts #268 -030 - vinyl damping material #260 – 317 - Acousta-stuf Crossovers #260 – 142 - Dayton 2.5 kHz #269 - 342 - Exacta 2.5 kHz Crossover Speakers Woofer: #299 -182 - Peerless 6.5 in (91.5 db eff) Tweeter: #279-125 - inexpensive $8.80 silk dome #264-555 - Vifa XT25TG30 - dual concentric #276-514 - ScanSpeak 9900 revelator Aperiodic Vent #296-546 - ScanSpeak aperiodic vent Wire: Buy 14 feet of flat wire from Madisound. You just several hours of spare time, a little urethane glue, some spray lacquer and a little knowledge and you have a fantastic speaker, better than any of the ARs and as good as many of the $3000 speakers. Similar Products Used: Vandersteen, Von Schweikert VR-3s and 4s, Rogers LS3.5as, etc. |
[May 31, 2002]
sam9
Audio Enthusiast
Strength:
Narrow depth makes it easy to place in some circumstances. Relatively "full range" given the size - definately not a satellite speaker. Assembly is super simple - under one hour - only Homer Simpson could screw it up!
Weakness:
A couple of missing components when delivered. Quickly corrected, but... Wish they offered a bare MDF version. Very good speaker for the size or price. Easy to build. A couple of quality /customer service issues that don't sound. Although there are a number of good ~$200 /pair speakers on the market, this one of the better ones. If you are a DIYer, you might think about eventually building a better XO - this one is a very simple first order. It works, but I'll bet it could be improved on. Overall, better sound for $175 than you will normally find off the shelf Similar Products Used: AR, CSW, Advent M&K None were kits |
[May 27, 2002]
PMartinez
Audio Enthusiast
Strength:
Beautiful sound. Good looking. Very inexpensive. Blows away speakers costing $8000 or more.
Weakness:
Hard to resell due to little known vendor. This review is for the Madisound Odin speakers. This speaker is a dual Seas 6.5" configuration with a Seas Excel tweeter. The configuration is a vented box with the drivers above and below the tweeter. The kit comes with a state of the art crossover and some good damping material. I added additional padding for the sides of the box. It takes about 2 hours to assemble both and the result is spectacular. I have currently loaned this set out to an enthusiast who was blown away by the clean, detailed midrange and finely detailed highs. The cabinet is a nicely constructed, 'Chinese' box with oak veneer in either black or white. Similar Products Used: Von Schweikert, Hales, Allison, PSB, DIY |
[Nov 18, 1999]
Matt Dru
Audio Enthusiast
Strength:
Good overall sound, very effeciant
Weakness:
Needs help on the bass response. This is a sealed enclosure design so the bass is very tight and clean but not a large presence. I am using these as read surround speakers and have been very happy with their performance. I was using these as my mail speakers during a relocation and was surprised at their overall sound quality and effeciency. They are not as warm as my Dynaudio orbitals but are almost as clean. |
[Sep 27, 1999]
Vandit Kalia
an Audio Enthusiast
I second the previous comment about this speaker. No, it isnt the last word in audioweenie characteristics or bass response. However, it is pretty damned musical - far more than a $165 speaker should be. |
[Dec 26, 1999]
Jason
Audio Enthusiast
Strength:
The bass is tight. and the tremble is clear.
Weakness:
The cross over design. The speaker is good for its value. I got mine for $185 because I upgraded it to the real oak box. The real oak box is a bit bigger and more heavy. Madisound didn't spend much time on designing the crossover. It's just a first order, simple design. I think the speaker can do better if Madisound can provide a better crossover. If you have less than 200 dollars budget on a pair of speakers, I would suggest you listen to psb mini, mission 731i etc. If none of them can satify you, then try this one. |
[May 12, 2001]
Regis Gravlin
Audiophile
Strength:
Very musical, PRICE!!!, clean and tight.
Weakness:
crossover and bass is too lean. My friend purchased these and I put them, together. Similar Products Used: Paradigm, |
[Sep 21, 1999]
J.S.
an Audio Enthusiast
If your into kits (building speakers from a kit), where you are supplied the cabinets and components, and all you have to do is run a screwdriver, you'll like this one. It's a small 2 way speaker using a Madisound 6102 woofer, Vifa D20TD05 tweeter, and one of Madisound's in house designed Sledgehammer crossovers. You can put together a pair in an evening. Great sound, nice sound stage, very musical for the price. These don't produce a ton of bass, but what do you expect from a small pair of bookshelf speakers? Match these with a good self powered sub, and brag to all your friends how little you spent, and you built them yourself (don't tell them all it took was a screwdriver and a little time). Madisound has other kits for sale too at www.madisound.com, but I can't speak for their sound quality. Anyway, I highly recommended the Sledgelings for the money, and the supplied cabinets are of high quality. |