Magnepan Magneplanar MG 1.6 Floorstanding Speakers
Magnepan Magneplanar MG 1.6 Floorstanding Speakers
[May 01, 1999]
Jim
an Audiophile
I'm submitting this review not as an owner or even prospective buyer of the Maggies, but as a lover of music. I have had a lot of recent listening to these speakers in the process of making a decision on purchasing a new CD player, while they have been hooked up to a variety of mid-priced electronics (B&K, Rotel, and Adcom top end amps and preamps; Rotel 971 and 991, Adcom 750, and Arcam Alpha 9 CD players). In a nutshell, these are amazing speakers for the money: natural highs, detailed and seamless mids, and believe it or not, lows that extend down with power to 35 Hz or so. They throw a wide and deep soundstage, are musical, dynamic, and very accurate tonally. Yes, I said dynamic: these speakers will slam you pretty well on rock or a symphonic crescendo. They are utterly unfatiguing to listen to, yet open up the details of the music. For $3000 these would be very good speakers; for the $1475 they retail for they are a great deal. If I didn't live in a household with a 6 year old, an 8 year old, a large and clumsy Labrador retriever and most importantly, a cat who likes to sharpen her claws on anything vertical I'd be selling my current speakers and buying these, but I figure the potential for damage to the ribbon tweeter and midrange drivers is too likely here. |
[May 25, 1999]
pam
an Audio Enthusiast
Well, I did it. I made the mistake of auditioning a set of Maggie MG-12's when I went in to pick up a set of B&W 602's and wound up spending $400 more than I'd intended (they made me take them home!). Several weeks later, my dealer offered to let me trade them in on a set of 1.6's they'd been using as demo's for a couple hundred more. So, since I figured these silver-white things would brighten up the room more (the black MG-12's seemed a bit dark), I made the trade-up. Every bit as good as the MG-12's but with better bass and a bit more realistic imaging. I can't get over how they sound on piano (even to the pedal sounds) or reeds, and if I close my eyes on this one latin CD, I'd swear one of the guitar players was sitting right in a chair I have placed on the wall several feet to the side of the speakers. Amazing soundstage! Just wish I could have afforded to keep the MG-12's for rear speakers on my HT setup (unlike my old speakers, I find I don't need a center-channel speaker with these and rarely even bother turning the subwoofer on for movies anymore ).Equipment: Yamaha RX-V995 reciever, Pioneer 606d DVD and Yamaha CDC 665 cd player. |
[Jun 11, 1999]
Paul Hauser
an Audiophile
Well, I really think it's about time everybody finally woke up and smelled the coffee!! Magnepan has made a great and reasonably priced product line for quite a while. I first found out about this co. about 20 years ago when I was 15 or so. A cousin of mine had a small pair like the SMG's and the first time I heard them I was just blown away! And that was 20 years ago!! Right then and there I knew if I could ever scrounge up the cash I was gonna buy Magnepan's. |
[Jul 16, 1999]
Seyhun
an Audiophile
I listen to music seriosly at home, but also have a system and listening room at work. I used to have Monitor Audio Studio 6 speakers connected to 2 Mono tube PP amplifiers. I tried the Magnepan 1.6 QR with a Classe DR-25 first to replace these, and bought the Magnepan immediately. Then tried it with my tube amps, and there was the miracle. The best sounding system in my listening room until that time. |
[Jul 11, 1999]
Tim Zdrale
an Audiophile
I have been in this hobby for 20 years and finally found a speaker that in a very reasonalble price range "blew me away!" I can't think of any speaker regardless of pricerange (except for the Magnepan 3.6's} that even come close.I remember listening to the Magnepans (5) years ago and thought they just don't have any bass! The 1.6's are a technological breakthrough! I have never enjoyed listening to music so much! I recently sold a pair of Hales Revelation 2's because I just wasn't satisfied with them. The 1.6's do everything right; vocals, midrange and mid-bass, bass. With out a doubt one of the best buys I have ever made in my life!! This is one speaker that is a keeper for a loooong |
[Aug 31, 1999]
Curt
an Audio Enthusiast
After reading all of the enthusiastic reviews on this speaker, especially the comparisons to the Martin Logans Aerius' that many people have made, I had my cash in hand, being excited at the prospect of purchasing these $1400.00 speakers that "sounded better" than the $2400.00 Martin Logan speakers which I love so well. But when my wife and I got to the audio store and auditioned these speakers, I couldn't believe what I heard. My listening experience was so disappointing, I felt that something had to be wrong with the Rotel CD player and amps (Top of the line Adcoms) that the Maggies were hooked up to. Thinking this HAD to be the case, I asked the store manager to hook these speakers to the high priced amps in their elite listening room, thinking that these speakers were sure to impress. I almost had to ask the salesperson if these were actually 1.6QRs. In short, the music was "just there". Uninvolving to say the least. After spending the past month auditioning speakers between the price ranges of $500.00 to $3500.00, I would definitely say that these Maggies sound like $1200.00 speakers, nothing more. As always, you get what you pay for. |
[Sep 03, 1999]
Dibesh Shrestha
an Audiophile
This is my second review for the Maggie 1.6/QR. |
[Aug 26, 1999]
THE DON
an Audio Enthusiast
Kyle |
[Sep 09, 1999]
Hmmmm
an Audio Enthusiast
Let me tell you something. If you don't listen to rap, there is no other speaker that can come close to 1.6QRs!!! Seriously how can Magnepan make a speaker like this and charges only $1500. Don't you want to be in the same room with Tom Petty when he is singing? I do! 100 stars!!!! |
[Sep 13, 1999]
C Kim
an Audiophile
I have just spent the last 4 months reading magazines, surfing AV web sites and traveling all over my area to audition speakers, and finally, my search is over for the best speakers my money can buy. I went to a dealer that carried Magnepans. I had read about them before. I first listened to the 3.6 then to the1.6 and was absolutely blown away by both. They made me excited to listen to music. They sounded so smooth and life-like that I was surprised that I was listening to reproduced music. When listening to these speakers I did not have to consciously try imagine anything, everything was so obviously 'there' that I could stop critiquing and begin listening. I know there are no perfect speakers but great sounding speaker for me at a good price. This speaker is natural and throws and excellent and dynamic soundstage. No other speaker does not compete with this at the $1500 price range. After broken in it sounds better even feel few hertz go down to lower base. |