Magnepan Magneplanar MG 1.6 Floorstanding Speakers
Magnepan Magneplanar MG 1.6 Floorstanding Speakers
[May 11, 2007]
Foehn
Audio Enthusiast
Strength:
Incredibly detailed and smooth.
Weakness:
Can't think of any right now. Granted I've only had them for a few hours.
Just got these speakers set up tonight. Bought the demo pair that the dealer had.
Customer Service N/A Similar Products Used: Any Definitive Technology speaker you can think of. I've probably had it.
|
[Apr 26, 2007]
wpm
AudioPhile
Strength:
Possess all the attributes that Magneplanars are renowned for: speed, transparency, sound staging, etc.
Weakness:
Voiced a bit too high in the mid/treble region for my liking. Somewhat thinner sounding bass when compared to other Maggies. First, let me state for the record that I am a Magnepan user. I have owned numerous models, off and on, for over 20-years. So, it is with great pain that I write the following comments: My intention is not to discredit, only to educate, and perhaps save someone the trouble I have gone through when selecting this model.
Similar Products Used: (See review) |
[Mar 18, 2007]
washburn1
Audio Enthusiast
Strength:
over all a great speaker from the tight base to the crisp highs. The way the fill a room with sound is unbelevable.
Weakness:
NONE Just my opinion I just purchased my magneplaners and would like to take some time to clue you in.
Similar Products Used: b&w, definitive not realy similar |
[Feb 28, 2007]
Larry L Hoffman
Audio Enthusiast
Strength:
Fantastic soundstage (as good as my Grados), realism (on good CDs like being there live), ability to pick out even background information (voices and instruments)
Weakness:
Bass cuts off below 40-50 hz. Don't let cats or kittens near them (look like very nice cat trees). This was my first foray into the realm of ribbon/planar/electrostatic speakers, and it already has not been my last. The 1.6QR Maggies are undoubtedly the best speakers I have purchased (until perhaps getting a pair of used IICs). They replace a fine set of Forte's by Klipsch and easily outperform them in many ways. Voices are especially clear, and many minor instrumental nuances are revealed for the first time when listening to the Maggies.
Customer Service Great support available from Magnepan. Similar Products Used: Only mid to high-end cone speakers (Eososne, Klipsch, NHT, Bose, etc.) |
[Jan 13, 2007]
danilo
AudioPhile
Strength:
transparent, no source for sound in the room, easy listening
Weakness:
power, power, and .....time.
coming from SMG i was going to some other speakers then back to Magneplanar.
Customer Service no idea (luky now) Similar Products Used: smg/c |
[Nov 28, 2006]
blackraven
Audio Enthusiast
Strength:
Great imaging and sound stage
Weakness:
Size
I just purchased a pair off Magnepan Q1.6 speakers 2 weeks ago after owning a pair of the MMG's for 7 years. I compaired them to Martin Logans, NHT's, Mg12's and several other high end speakers. There is nothing under $5,000 dollars that compares to them. Even it's little brother the MG12's don't compare. The 1.6's have a much fuller and warmer sound then the MG12's. The base is much deeper, so much so that you don't need a subwoofer unless you're a base fanatic and like that boomy base. The imaging and sound stage are superb and the speakers fill my 17'x17' room with 9' ceilings full of sound where ever you sit. They have a much larger sweet spot than the MMG and MG12's. Much has been said about Magnepan's not sounding good at low volumes, but the 1.6's sound excellent at low volume levels. If your looking at buying the MG 12's and you can afford the extra $700 and have the space, then go for the Q1'6's.
Similar Products Used: MMG's
|
[May 22, 2006]
RSDBN
Audio Enthusiast
Strength:
Very warm and transparant sound stage. Will work with even modest amps. Look great, very thin and modern style. Sound better than other speakers costing two or three times as much. A great value - new or used. Also from what I have seen, retain their value quite well.
Weakness:
Can't blast 'em like a good rock and roll speaker. But not really a true weakness and they are not a rock and roll speaker. I just purchased the 1.6 speakers from a private owner. Set them up and all I can say is WOW! The sound is very impressive. Very warm and transparent sound. Completely fills the room. My system is moderate including a 100 watt McIntosh receiver, Pioneer direct drive turntable and CAL tube CD player. They require the volume knob to be cranked up significantly higher thaqn with my former Klipch Chorus speakers for the approximate same listening level. Great sound and value. Highly recommended. Customer Service Excellent. I called the company for advice on placement, etc. Very knowledgable and helpful. Also offered to send me at no charge the original documents that came with the speakers as the original owner had misplaced them. Similar Products Used: Klipsch Chorus II |
[Nov 29, 2005]
mhardman2005
Audio Enthusiast
Strength:
Clear, lifelike, transparent, especially on acoustic music & vocals
Weakness:
Limited bass extension & volume, size, demanding on amplification. Started off with the smaller MMGs which, although they sounded nice, were limited in the bass and in volume. The replacement 1.6s seem to play much louder, that is I've never run out of headroom whether on music or movies. The Magneplanar sound is such that, once you've had it, you'll never go back to box speakers. The box colouration is totally absent, and instruments & singers sound big and remarkably lifelike, almost like they're in the room. The Maggies have a reputation for being a bit energetic in the treble, but with my tube pre-amp and Adcom power amp, they have the very unusual combination of being clear & detailed and yet totally unfatiguing. They thrive on acoustic & vocals, try Eric Clapton Unplugged and all I can say is wow! The above comments for music apply equally well for surround, I use a subwoofer to take some pressure off the Maggies in the bass and the resulting sound with Maggies on all 4 channels is amazing. A Maggie centre is available but you don't really need one. |
[Oct 17, 2005]
Steve Bob
Audio Enthusiast
Strength:
musicians are in the room
Weakness:
They can be imposing After being in the busines back during the 70's, I don't like to pay retail. I've been impressed by the bigger M'pans but never had the chance to buy right (I'm cheap). These are the best buy on the market. The imaging and cocohesiveness is outstanding Similar Products Used: Dalquist, Rectilinear, Advent, Polk, Paradign, NHT, Infinity, Vandersteen |
[Sep 30, 2005]
manny55
AudioPhile
Strength:
Transparency,imaging,tonality,speed,soundstaging,naturalness of bass,dynamic graduations,Coherence with a capital C!
Weakness:
Their tall,but elegant.If not properly placed they can sound from overly fuzzy and warm to thin and bright. I've been in Audio for about 30 years and I must say I've heard a lot of speakers in my life time.I won't repeat what has already been said about the magnepan 1.6qr.All I want to say is that for the price I don't know of any other speakers in the world that gets it all together the way this speaker does.The transparency is breathtaking.The liquidity of the sound , total absence of grain at the price is a miracle to behold,if properly match with the electronics.The soundstage is colosal.Proper placement is an important issue because if not,you just won't get what she is capable of.They can sound bright and fuzzy, no sound stage depth,bass can became from thin to overblown.The size of the panels might cause havok with your spouse, and if you have pets buying a pet repelent is a must.Apart from these issue,there just isnt much else to say that hasn't already been said about them.Oh yeah,they are power hungry if you like your sound loud.Word of caution!Their sound is addictive.Not because of eufonic colorations but because their performance merits your undivded atention because of its unnerving musicality. Similar Products Used: Spica TC-50,ProAc studio 100,Magnepan smg a , Magnepan 1.4,thiel 1.2 |