Magnepan Magneplanar MG20 and 20.1 Floorstanding Speakers
Magnepan Magneplanar MG20 and 20.1 Floorstanding Speakers
USER REVIEWS
[Nov 15, 1998]
Mr Happy
an Audio Enthusiast
Well, firstly, I hate to gush over a set of speakers like this, but they are so damn good I think they deserve it. I have had the pleasure of listening to a fair portion of the Magnepan's speaker line up from the 1.5's, 2.7's to the 3.5R's and have never ceased to be amazed. I really tend to agree with those that say once you have heard the planar sound you never feel like going back to a conventional box/cone speaker. Planar speakers are far more intimate, exposed and startlingly life like than even the best conventional speakers I have ever heard. After listening to planar speakers, conventional speakers sound like you are listening to live music through holes in a wall rather than live and in person. The human voice is reproduced so accurately and intimately it is even a little unnerving at first. The only significant weaknesses I could find was in terms of dynamics, low end reproduction, and small sweet spot (necessitating proper placement). It became quicky apparent that all these problems were inversely proportional to the planar radiating area. The bigger the planar bass driver became the better the dynamics got, the larger the sound stage became, and the lower the ultimate frequency response became. The MG20's are Magnepan's top of the line speaker that stand over six and a half feet tall. They are full up from 25 Hz to 40 kHz and have dynamics that could satisfy any sane human being. The MG20's reproduced a wide variety of music (jazz, classical, organ pieces, even hard rock) with uncanny realism and with seemingly no limit to dynamic load. The bass was incredibly authoritative and immeasurably more accurate and controlled then even the best subwoofer. The MG20's had it all: uncanny truth of timbre, dynamics, accurate top to bottom reproduction, huge sound stage, and most importantly realism to die for. The only quirk it had was that the sound stage was too big and instrument size seemed universally exaggerated. Also, if you purchased these panels you would need to get impeccable electronics (these speakers would painfully reveal any flaw in the associated system) and enough power to light a small city. The MG20's I heard were bi-amped to a total of four Bryston 7Bst's. Oh, there is one other little draw back to these monsters, they cost over $9,000! Oh well, maybe in another life, I will just have to be happy with my Vandersteen 3A's. These speakers easily get a 5 rating. |
[Dec 15, 1999]
Bruce DeBonis
Audiophile
Strength:
huge soundstage; Very natural sound; very emotionally involving
Weakness:
Difficult to set up; need alot of power I love these speakers. Had ML Quest Z which were more detailed, dynamic, and accurate but just weren't as musical as I thought they should be. Realized after about a month that I made a mistake. After about two years, I purchased the MG20 (had maggie 2.5Rs before the MLs). The MG20s are detailed etc. but overall, they are the most musical and emotionally involving speaker I have heard. I used to pursue accuracy and detail in a belief that I would enjoy music more, but found the accuracy and musicallity were not tied tightly together. The MG20s are detailed, but you can find speakers that do this better but non are more satisfying. I am interested in cooresponding with anyone owning these speakers to compare setup tips. Like all panel dipoles, there are incredibly sensitive to room placement and seating location. Similar Products Used: Magnepan 2.5R; Martin Logan Quest Z |
[Oct 29, 2000]
Glenn Islat
Audiophile
Strength:
*Massive sounstage
Weakness:
*Requires a large room for optimal set-up. I have been upgrading magnepan speakers for the past 11 years. Once you hear the sound there is just no going back to a conventional box speaker. The soundstaging and instrument reproduction is phenomenal and effortless. Similar Products Used: *other magnepan speakers |
[Sep 30, 2000]
mustafa sav
Audiophile
Strength:
Efortless sound
Weakness:
none After receiving these speakers I have finally arrived at the sonic Nirvana. I am using the 135 W per channel McIntosh MC2000 tube amp Cardas Golden Cross Bi wire cables, Sony SCD-1 and the VPI TNT Turntable w JMW 12" Tonearm with Grado Referene Platinum cartridge as my sources. Similar Products Used: none |