Polk Audio RT5 Floorstanding Speakers
Polk Audio RT5 Floorstanding Speakers
USER REVIEWS
[Feb 18, 2003]
brigrizzme
Audio Enthusiast
Strength:
Clarity, warm sound, flat response, nice bass for such a compact speaker, great for Jazz music and acoustics. Rubber instead of foam surrounds.
Weakness:
Durability. They are nice when they are working. I would first like to state that I have always been a huge POLK AUDIO fan. I am very impressed with the sound quality of every speaker in the Reference Theater line. I purchased these speaker new in 1997 because of the way they represented brass in Jazz music. I thoroughly enjoyed their sound until one of my drivers froze. I knew it could be replaced so I set up a time to take it to my Polk retailer for repair. This is about the time the tweeter in my other RT-5 stopped working. I never over or under power my speakers. The warranty that came with the speakers covered the repair but I was without music for 2 weeks. I suggest owning a pair of these speakers only if you have another pair for reserve. Similar Products Used: KEF K140, Klipsch KG5.5, Polk RT-16, Klipsch Quartet. -All powered with the same Adcom GFA 545 that the RT-5's were powered with. |
[Jul 02, 2002]
Philip Canard
Audio Enthusiast
Strength:
The sound! Also has better build quality than the price would suggest.
Weakness:
None at this price point. These are NOT the best you can get if you can spend twice their price or more (Try the Vandersteen 1C). These are for value-minded people, not the well-heeled that can afford the best. These aren't the world's best speaker, they are just the best speakers in the world at their price, at least as far as I have heard. They have a lot more going for them than just their "bang for the buck": easy to find on the used market (including the upgraded models RT35 and RT38i), made well enough to last a long time, very efficient which means they are a good match for low-powered tube amps, fairly good looking, good warranty support if you buy new, dealers everywhere, and easy to resell later. I have used them with a B&K ST-202+, Heathkit W5M, and am now using them with my Conrad-Johnson MF2250 while my new VMPS speaker kit is being put together. I especially like them with the Heathkit tube amp. The Conrad-Johnson really brings out the best in them, but a $2295 retail amp is too much for these little things. I found that they do not sound their best until broken in for several days, even weeks. The break in process had to be repeated after I let them sit in storage for 2 years after my last move. I will probably upgrade the crossover capacitor on the tweeter after my VMPS speakers are built in the next couple of weeks. They work best in a smaller room. I am using mine in the bedroom right now, and the balance is about right. They can sound midrange forward in a larger room, as the bass will be a bit lightweight. The bass is tight, however, with very good definition for this price range. They are perhaps the best audio purchase for the money that I ever made. The perfect loudspeaker for value-minded collectors of low powered vintage tube amps of less than 50 watts that want a compact monitor style loudspeaker that is efficient and mates very well with tubes. Similar Products Used: Some small monitor speakers I built myself for about $200. Not as good overall. You usually get a better deal by buying used in mint condition than building yourself from new components. |
[Jan 29, 2000]
Hal Welch
Audio Enthusiast
Strength:
Great Sound, Well Built, Bang for the Buck I picked up a pair of these fine speakers from Circuit City Similar Products Used: Klipsch KG2 |
[Jul 20, 1999]
Nazri
an Audio Enthusiast
HiI posted my review below previously. I would like to make extra comments. |
[Jul 02, 1998]
Jeff Smit
an Audiophile
I recently got these as a surround speaker for my home theater. I use 2 pairs. I tried them for Music and they are just fantastic, they provided everything I expected from a mid-priced Bookshelf speaker. For Home Theater they are pretty good but the bass is not anywhere near satisfying. The Vocals however are very clear. The highs were not perfect but were very detailed and weren't over emphasized. |
[Jul 05, 1998]
Mike Johnston
an Audiophile
I just bought a pair of RT5 speakers home from Circuit City to try them in my own (music-listening, two-speaker) office system. I find them bright, despite the fact that my system is vinyl-based and I used speaker cables (Sumiko OCOS) that are on the smooth and warm side (with grainier heavy-guage zipcord they're awful). They've got some good qualities--lots of detail and smooth treble principally. But the deficient bass isn't compensated for by a lovely or luscious midrange, as I generally prefer. On soft- or full-sounding records (Johnny Cash's "I Walk The Line" for example) they sound good, bringing out more detail and transient attack that I'm used to. But on brighter, more processed-sounding recordings (Golden Palominos right now), they haven't got much to offer. Vocals are okay but juuuust short of being edgy and thin. |
[Jun 30, 1998]
Ronzo
a Casual Listener
After reading a glowing review of the RT5's in Stereophile Magazine, I decided I had to hear them for myself. I was in the market for a decent pair of inexpensive ($300 or less) bookshelves, and the RT5's seemed to fit the bill. So I went to my local Polk Audio dealer (Circuit City) and gave them a good listen. I used Arturo Sandoval's Latin Train CD to demo them, and Circuit City used an Onkyo amp/preamp to supply power. Here are my impressions: |
[Jul 10, 1998]
Rich Simpson
an Audio Enthusiast
Despite what other members on this board say, I and a number of friends wholeheartedly disagree. I auditioned mine at The Good Guys (although I purchased from Crutchfield) along with speakers from Yamaha (typical Japanese speakers-crap) Klipsch, Sony (crap) Energy, Bose, and a few others that escape my memory. FOR THE PRICE, (key here-OF COURSE $1000 speakers sound better!) they were the best I heard. In fact, they were superior to speakers that cost up to about $500 by other brands. The highs are crisp and clean, the midrange is smooth, and bass is tight, though a bit lacking. Opera and classical music sound absolutely incredible on these, jazz and big band are impressive, and rock is about average-not quite enough bass oomph for most. Team these with a good subwoofer and you've got a system that will blow away most tower speakers. I'd just like to note that a friend of mine who used to build speakers with a small, now defunct audiophile speaker company called RTR and who is an audiophile with a complete Linn system and has friends with $10,000 systems was extremely impressed by the sound of these on songs like Sarah McLachlan's "Angel," where the vocals are incredibly clear and by the theme from "Bohemian Girl" by Puccini. Listen for yourself! These speakers are the best thing for the price and then some. |
[Jul 12, 1998]
Bob
an Audio Enthusiast
Polk Audio RT5 Bookshelf Speakers |
[Jun 16, 1998]
Ronzo
a Casual Listener
Polk Audio RT5 Bookshelf Speakers |