Toshiba SD-2300 DVD Players
Toshiba SD-2300 DVD Players
[Feb 26, 2001]
Eloy Lujan
Audio Enthusiast
Toshiba SD2300 DVD player has a new feature called NUON compatibility. We are starting to see the game consoles and DVD players merge. PS2 plays DVD discs, but now DVD players starting to be able to allow you to play games. |
[Feb 19, 2001]
Brett Heitkam
Audio Enthusiast
Strength:
NUON-capable (never tried it), Background Capture function
Weakness:
Everything (this player is junk) I bought this DVD player because it was new, top of the line, and a Toshiba, which all my friends told me was the best brand (I had been opting for Sony). When i saw the SD-2300 had all those awesome extra features and was NUON-capable, I bit on February first. Unfortunately, I didn't discover this website until February 17th. Well, using this machine during the majority of February, I experienced lengthy pauses at layer changes, pixellation, lock-ups, mysterious video noise on hi-definition digitally filmed movies, and numerous other problems. Something bad always had to happen with every DVD I played. Finally I found this site and I read other reviews on this product and realized I'd bought a lemon. EVERYONE was having these same problems! The next day, I took it back to Best Buy and exchanged it for a Panasonic RV-30 that was $100 cheaper and has a lot less extra bells and whistles, but so far it's been doing me no wrong. Great picture, great sound...it's just great. Whatever you do, do not buy a Toshiba...oh, an interesting sidenote: when I was at Best Buy returning my 2300, I saw four other people standing in line with various other models of Toshiba DVD players waiting to return them. I just sighed and rolled my eyes. "Yep, Toshiba's are really the best," my friends said...how wrong they were... Similar Products Used: Sansui (first DVD player 2 years ago), Panasonic RV-30 |
[May 17, 2001]
Onobori-san
Audio Enthusiast
Strength:
Great picture quality
Weakness:
Occasional pixilation on imported "rented" DVDs. So far I am quite satisfied with this DVD player. I bought this last December and so far I have not experienced any of the numerous problems listed here by others. I admit have seen some pixilation on some rented DVDs but these could have been due to scratches. Also, I had problems viewing a track of Das Boot. But here, again, the DVD was scratched. I just skipped the chapter and was able to resume watching the DVD. Similarly, a few other foreign DVDs had similar, albeit minor, problems. This is annoying and I have attributed this to dirty disks. So far I have watched about 20-30 DVDs and I cannot say that I am dissatisfied with this unit. Incidentally, my unit was one of those that needed a software upgrade. I did not notice nuch difference after the upgrade but I was later told that the upgrade had to do with the NUON part of the DVD player. Similar Products Used: Panasonic, Sony, JVC |
[May 17, 2001]
Glen Mullan
Audio Enthusiast
Strength:
Features
Weakness:
Audio CDs drop out, freeze; DVD pixellation This is my third DVD player, & third lemon. The Sony was junk: wouldn't play older audio CDs. The Panasonic was really junk: played audio CDs, but progressively lost it with DVDS. Similar Products Used: panasonic 501; a Sony |
[Jan 15, 2001]
Nathan
Audiophile
Strength:
Everything
Weakness:
None Well let me start by saying JVC sucks. Sony was alright but the whenever I played cd/dvd in it it sounded like it was going to take off. Returned the sony got the sd-2150. Simply didn't like it. Menus were slow and dvds took forever load. Transport didn't work like I thought it should. Returned it and got the sd-1600. transport was kinda loud and layer changes were more than noticable. sometimes I would have to try a dvd 3 times for it to load. returned it and picked up the sd-2300. I love it. image is much much sharper. image is better all around. Sound is a step above all the rest of em too. I have not noticed any pixelation to speak of. layer changes are not noticable at all. also, I can't even hear the cd/dvd spinning with my ear on the player. Maybe I just got lucky? This dvd player is great and best buy evenly exchanged it for the sd-1600 because of the hassle I've had. Similar Products Used: Toshiba SD-1600, 2150. JVC 501BK. Sony S360. |
[Jan 15, 2001]
Andrew
Audiophile
Strength:
You can turn it off and return it. Also it burns rather easily if you decide to ignite it like I did.
Weakness:
More flaws then the Russian economy. This is by far one of the worst dvd players on the market. I have been with DVD since it first came out and this is ridiculus for a 4th generation model. The pixelation is horrid. It fills up the whole screen with green boxes and sometimes only parts of the screen with black or white squares. Truly a piece of junk. If you gave this to a bum he would throw it back at you. I was more impressed with the cardboard box it came in then the dvd player itself. Similar Products Used: Sonys, Panasonics, Pioneers, Philips, and many more. |
[Jan 15, 2001]
Mike Wolert
Audio Enthusiast
Strength:
Cool remoth and 16x zoom
Weakness:
EVERYTHING. Image pixelated and had millions of artifacts. The whole screen would pixelate like 3 times per a movie. Slow loading the menus on dvds. Layer changes take forever and many more weaknesses. And stupid Nuon only features that are not worth the extra money. Do not buy this dvd player. The image pixelates in every dvd you put in it. I thought mine was defective but the one I exchanged it with did the same thing. This thing also takes forever to load menus and to do layer changes. The Nuon feature is a waste of $$$ and the games for it suck. Get the Pioneer 333 or if you must get a Toshiba dvd player get the SD-1600 its 100 bucks less and has better image quality and it doesnt pixelate. If you buy this dvd player after reading this review and have the same problems I had dont say I didnt warn you. Similar Products Used: Pioneer 333, Toshiba SD-1600, Sony 560D |
[Jan 14, 2001]
Brian
Strength:
Great features
Weakness:
Well... The player seems to be well built and has excellent effects, along with a good mix of fast forward/reverse/slow-mo speeds. But, of the 20 or so mint-condition discs played, 4 of them brought out the ugliness of this machine. On occasion, the player would freeze- the audio and video would just stop. Other times, the video would freeze, and the audio would play for a few more seconds, then stop. In one instance, Titanic locked up in the middle of a scene, and my only option was to shut off the unit. Haven't had a chance to try out any of the nuon features. |
[Jan 12, 2001]
Terry
Casual Listener
Strength:
Very nice NUON Effects. Good remote and options on DVD Player.
Weakness:
Will not play at least 1 movie so far. The Layer change on any movie produces and pause. The SD2300 is a very nice DVD Player...except for a couple things. It will not play Mission to Mars at all. I Rented 2 copies of this movie to watch...and it just tells me the "Disc is Loading" and never actually plays. The second problem I have with it is at every layer change there is a noticeable PAUSE...and then it moves on. Just an annoyance really. Besides these problems I love this DVD player. With the high color overlayed menu's and all the extra-special features it has...It's a very good choice! Similar Products Used: PC-DVD Components |
[Mar 13, 2001]
James Stewart
Audio Enthusiast
Strength:
Digital Filtered Zoom, smooth special effects.
Weakness:
What good is the ZOOM & effects when you cant watch a single dvd w/o experiencing problems? Its not the nuon technology that sucks...its TOSHIBA...Period! I decided to try this unit given the fact that the models serial #s werent included in the firmware upgrade. But guess what? It STILL gave me problems! Its the same exact problems the MAJORITY of Toshibas have...Pixelation, freezing. Mine gave me something new...picture freeze while the audio was still going! THE HELL with firmware upgrades! Nothing this new should require that when other units out there DONT! EVERY SINGLE DVD I threw at it over the weekend had something go wrong! The MATRIX-pixeld, Meet the Parents-pixeld, The Contender-pixeld, & froze...The Bodyguard-pixeld...etc, I was very upset because the zoom allowed to reduce the black bars...but to what end? I'd rather have a thick as hell letterbox movie than one that "glitches". I took this piece of crap back to BEST BUY and the idiot hooks the unit up, puts in a disc for approx ONE MINUTE!... and says, "I dont see anything wrong"...So I invited him to spend the weekend with me viewing about 10 movies, but he said he couldnt do that...then I said..."Then dont make idiot statements just because you put in a movie for a big whopping minute!" (Straight out of high school and they think they're "techs" cause they work behind a counter and can figure out how to plug somthing into a wall...)So I went to get the Pansonic RV30 (based on very good long term reviews) guess what? They're being discontinued! All thats on the shelf are crappy sonys & TOSHIBAS! ARGHHHHHHHH!!!! Then I saw the Pioneer DVC503 (5disc changer) My butt clenched because I DIDNT read ANY REVIEWS on this! I took it home last night...hooked it up, and played THE MATRIX...SMOOTH all the way through (The picture was better as well. The Toshibas had a dark image..EVEN with the settings OFF!) Then this morning I came to work, logged on, held my breath for the reviews and score on the Pioneer and was pleasently surprised! 4.21 out of 5! My fingers are crossed that this will hold up....I mean what the hell, I had a PHILLIPS for a YEAR before any problems surfaced! RUN from a TOSHIBA!!! the few good ones out there dont make up for the MANY LEMONS! How could a company (Toshiba) who was in on the dvd technology consistently SCREW up? Since PIONEER "pioneered" Laser discs in the 70's I'm hoping on the DVD...will keep ya posted. Similar Products Used: Phillips Magnavox |