Martin Logan ReQuest Floorstanding Speakers
Martin Logan ReQuest Floorstanding Speakers
[Jun 25, 2000]
Dennis
Audiophile
This is an addendum to my earlier review. |
[Jul 31, 2001]
jimmy diego
Audiophile
Strength:
Clarity, transparencies, reality
Weakness:
need careful tuning and positioning and equipments to support it. As an US MArine veteran I would not go around beating the bushes. Lets talk straight-talk..... Similar Products Used: Jensen electro static, AUdio lab ribbons, Strathearns ribbons, Heco speakers (germany), Infinity, Electro Voice horns, dahlquist, old martin logans, Watt Puppy wilson audio. Revox, tandberg, westrex |
[Dec 13, 1999]
David
Audio Enthusiast
Strength:
Clarity, definition
Weakness:
Slightly bass-shy I bought a pair in October. They're still breaking in, and I grow more impressed each day. My setup: |
[Dec 14, 1999]
dave
Audio Enthusiast
Strength:
impressive clarity and detail
Weakness:
driver integration and construction Thanks to Andrew for finally letting out the "little secret" of Martin Logan's lousy build quality. Impressed with ML's apparently great value per dollar? Just get out the trusty screwdriver and do a quick comparison between their speaker construction (especially in the woofer enclosures) and ANY other high end speaker manufacturer. They get away with murder because listeners (myself included) are so captivated by the electrostatic sound they are willing to forgive inadequacies that other manufacturers would get pilloried over! Wonder why the bass response is always the Achille's heel of ML speakers? Try flimsy enclosures, cheap drivers and 1970's crossover and transformer technology. I WANT to love these speakers, believe me. I went from a CJ Premier 11a to bridged Spectral DMA 90's to Cary SLM 200's, but no change in amplification could cure what is fundamentally flawed driver technology and integration. It was not an easy decision to trade to WATT/ Puppies, but I can tell you there is a LOT more music to be enjoyed (even without that glorious electrostatic panel) when the speaker is capable of meaningfully revealing the lower frequencies. That said, I'm told there is a new speaker coming out from ML called the Prodigy, and that it is supposedly built to much higher standards, using drivers, enclosures and crossovers that are commensurate with an $11,000 product. Hopefully, I'll hear it at the CES next month and, if its something to get excited about, I'll update this posting. Similar Products Used: aerius, SL-3, CLS IIZ |
[Oct 23, 2000]
Michael
Audio Enthusiast
Strength:
Image, Overall sound stage and reproduction
Weakness:
None yet, but I'm still trying to balance 2 channel & A/V use So far=excellent. Wonderful reproduction and very accurate. Maybe too much so for some folk. Bass is great, can't even describe mids and highs!,(bi-wired) but I'm still looking for correct settings for A/V. Similar Products Used: None - Replaced Polk SRTs |
[Apr 26, 2000]
David
Audiophile
Strength:
Good looks and finish - wonderful and realistic sound - incredible mid range and stunning highs
Weakness:
Cabinet finish could be more exotic Rather than leave a review on speakers that I don't OWN or have in my home - I just got my ReQuests - I waited 6 weeks for them to arrive - before I made the buying decision I listened to the the SL3's, The Prodigy and the ReQuests - I choose the ReQuests for its larger soundstage and better bass - I've been on an upgrade part since Novemebr and the ML's were the last in the chain - the setup is a bit complicated and they need to be at least 2.5 feet out from the wall and angled slightly - after an hour or so I was ready and right from the box they sounded incredible - I've had some great speakers - I just sold some Mirage M3Si's that I had for about 6 years and before that I had B&w's -the 808's, 801 and 802's - in comparing them I would have to say that the ML's are the closest to realism on the Mid's and highs of any speaker that I have owned or even auditioned within my price budget. I won't say that the ML's are nirvana -but they come close - and you have to have good electronics since the ML's are very revealing. Similar Products Used: Acoustat 4's, Mg2A's |
[Apr 10, 2000]
Steve
Audiophile
Strength:
good looks, sound, price
Weakness:
build quality, price Dave from Nevada, I agree with you 100% on the fact that ML does cut corners and build quality is awful but I do think their sound is impecable and their looks will impress almost every signifant other (maybe not the Statements). Similar Products Used: Magnepans and other ML products. |
[May 25, 2000]
mark mangiola
Audiophile
Strength:
open soundstage, natural mids and highs
Weakness:
bottom end/electronic selection
Similar Products Used: maggies quads |
[Nov 17, 1999]
gregg
Audio Enthusiast
Strength:
great accurate soundstage. unbelievable quickness.
Weakness:
price and size. the very best speaker i have heard or owned. i did not expect the bass impact...thought i'd need a sub-woofer. i do not! the build quality is exceptional. Similar Products Used: none. |
[Jul 20, 2001]
Jon Bertheussen
Audio Enthusiast
Strength:
Transparent, clarity, natural...etc etc
Weakness:
None particular IMHO. Some might want more level in treble, but you don't loose any information here. The treble just don't call for your attention. Analyst-freaks might be disappointed? Needs good amplification to give it's best, like Mark Levinson, Krell, Electrocompaniet and such. My first entry into high-end, and the ReQuest fits my ideals like a hand in the glove. Used with Sony XA-7ES CD-player. EC 4,5 pre-amp, EC AW-250R power-amp and MIT-cables. This setup plays music as you would hear it live. The AW-250R drives the ReQuest like a charm, and is a good match. The bass goes deep and with a very strong authority. The placement is a little important. Correct placed and with proper amplification the bass goes deep enough for me and has good punch. As another review mentioned. Someone has complained about poor bass. This is not a problem here, and I believe this is a problem if you choose a wrong placement and if you don't provide a good amplification with enough power to drive them. This speaker demands more than a $1k amp with 100W!! The mid-tones are the most delicate, clear and transparent I have ever heard, and the high-notes are just simply there. The soundstage is HUGE when used with Electrocompaniet. This speaker is ideal for acoustic music, vocals and playing the BLUES. Sorry...got to go, Stevie Ray Vaughan is just about to play "Little Wing" just for me. Press PLAY. My strongest recommendations. And I am not trading them in... |