Vandersteen 5 Floorstanding Speakers
Vandersteen 5 Floorstanding Speakers
USER REVIEWS
[Jan 01, 2002]
Doug Barry
Audio Enthusiast
Strength:
Too many to note, but their ability to fit into many placements is great. If you really want to understand these speakers, read Richard Hardesty's interview of RV, or buy the Audio Perfectionist journal from Hardesty. They need to be set up correctly and tweaked a bit, and I am still in the tweaking stage, but for all people who love music, just pure, accurate music, detail, soundstaging, etc., this is the speaker. I am a dedicated two channel advocate and these are now my speaker probably to the end. Upgradable too, and just do too many things to talk about here ( like having the built in powered subs with the dedicated bass amps and a high pass filter which allows you to use a musical amp for the mids and highs, without giving up base control and impact ).
Weakness:
Expensive and heavy, especially in the history of Vandersteen. A less expensive alternative is to use the 3A Signatures with the 2WQ subs and a high pass filter, see Hardesty's journal, etc. ( This is not a complaint, I thoroughly researched many speakers, many at a much higher price that I felt had much less overall performance ). Give them an audition from a reputable dealer who has them set up correctly in a good room, and who has burned in the associated electronics properly. If they are not set up correctly, you may get a bad impression. I urge anyone thinking of buying Vandersteen speakers, especially the 5's or the 3A Sigs with the 2WQ subs to open their mind and read a bit of Hardesty's material on the subject, and especially on using powered " musical " subs in addition to the full range speakers by using a high pass filter which allows a system approach to amps, power, and ultimate re-creation of music. Not boom box subs, musical low Q subs ( or at least adjustable like the 5's and 2WQ ). Similar Products Used: Magnepan MG3A's were my former speakers, for years. |
[Nov 15, 2001]
Dave
Audio Enthusiast
Strength:
Truely, the best, most complete speaker ever built. The best bass in the world. Totally natural uncompressed sound from top to bottom! Time and phase coherent. The ultimate value in the highest end speaker. Upgradeability & flexability like no other speaker.
Weakness:
None If you haven't heard a properly set up pair of Model 5s, go and do it right now. If you can appreciate the sound of natural instruments and human voices, you will fall in love. Also, with their 400 watt powered, 12" metal cone, push-pull internal subwoofers- along with the superb Vandersteen x-over system, they really do make the best, most extended and most articulate bass in the world. Bass that doesn't sound like a subwoofer! Similar Products Used: Nothing else really comes close. |
[Jul 17, 1999]
Marcello
an Audiophile
the Vanderstein 5's are The most insane speaker I have heard.I have Mine Hooked up to A BAT VK500 and A bat 5SE Pre amp and I have yeat to hear anything better.The active components in the speaker are A pair of 12" Aluminum Cone's "sub Woofer" smashed together with the voice coils starting at the top of one and ending at the bottom of the other.These are powered by a 400-watt Amplifier.This generates base that need's to be heard.The best words to describe this combo would be smoth and powerfull.you find your self being scared of the croschendos. |
[Aug 13, 1999]
AJP
an Audiophile
I listened to these the other day, all I can say is they gave me goosebumpslike no other speaker ever has! They absolutely blew the JM Lab Utopias away, |
[Sep 07, 1999]
David McCarthy
an Audiophile
The 5's have an open (very British) sound. With amps such as the Cary 805SE, you better be playing classical and jazz records. The setup is too slow for rock-n-roll. Like the Vandy 2's and 3's, the 5's do a great job with vocals. I haven't tried them with solid state amps. |
[Sep 16, 1999]
Yogi Saxena
an Audiophile
I have been seriously into audio for over 20 years. I started during 1974s with CD-4, Shibata Cartridge and four speakers sound with matching Amp. On moving to USA I brought my equipment along and believed until 1984 that it was the best sound I had heard. Well, this was not the first time I was wrong. I have been proven wrong again and again. Every time I think I have reached audio Nirvana, I find something better. |
[Nov 04, 1999]
Serious listener
Audiophile
Strength:
Plays loud and is a fine add to the furniture setting of a living room.
Weakness:
Very careful room treatments and placement are key; otherwise, imaging just doesn't happen. This is the flagship speaker in the line and when I heard it at a dealer's showroom, I felt tdhat it did not image well. Perhaps the dealer didn't set it up right. I was thankful that I had the 3A speakers which I thought and still think it is the greatest value for dthe money: $2,750 rather than $10,000. Similar Products Used: Vandersteen 3A speakers, Proacs, B&W |
[Oct 05, 1999]
Fred
a Casual Listener
When I heard the Vandersteen Fives the one thing that came to mind is that I was not listening to speakers. The music just floated above them.I was also suprised not to see any room treatment.When I asked how much for these John at Audio Connection said 9800 bucks.After that, I said somehow,someday. Give these a listen even if you can"t afford them. |
[Apr 07, 2000]
Jeff
Audio Enthusiast
Strength:
Draws you into the music like no other speaker
Weakness:
None I heard these at Audio Connection in Verona NJ and would highly recommend this place. This was the only speaker I have heard that could reproduce a Grateful Dead show similar to the smaller venues they played in the seventies. Micky Hart's drum solo was astonishing. I find the big difference between the Vandersteen and Martin Logan speakers is the Vandersteens present the entire musical experience, the Martin Logans are excellent speakers but often times you will find yourself picking out elements of the recording as opposed to listening to the music. If you enjoy live music give these speakers a listen and it will all make sense. Similar Products Used: Martin Logan, Theil, BW |
[Mar 29, 2001]
David McCarthy
Audiophile
Strength:
reproduction of vocal sound and transparency I would like to append an earlier review. Since the 1st review, I have upgraded my amps to Cary 1610's. With more power, the speakers sound quicker and tighter than they did matched with the Cary 805's. Super amp unless you like colored reproduction. 5 Stars!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Similar Products Used: B & W 801, Vandersteen 3A |